Why GM & CEO Hires Fail in Medium Sized Businesses
Many family and founder-led businesses do everything right: they grow quickly, build success, make acquisitions and appoint a General Manager or CEO. Yet the appointment fails, and the usual response is to blame the person. This interactive workshop challenges that assumption and asks whether the real problem is the environment the leader was hired into.
Adrian Nisbet shares the story of a GM appointment that went wrong and the ten years it took to see the real cause. Participants then discuss why capable leaders fail across very different businesses, from founder-led manufacturers to family retail groups, professional practices and fast-growth construction firms, and why the outcomes are so similar.
The session introduces four dimensions of leadership readiness: structure, operating environment, behaviour and culture, and founder and family. It then turns them into a practical diagnostic framework to test before hiring, covering direction, authority, accountability, operating environment, culture and founder/family readiness. A “founder test” explores what happens when the CEO makes a decision the founder disagrees with, and who really holds authority when things get uncomfortable.
Participants work through a realistic case study of a $25m family business whose founder wants a “really strong GM to take all this off me”. Tables decide whether they would recommend hiring, what concerns them, what they would address first, and what conversation the advisor needs to have with the founder.
The workshop contrasts two sequences, “hire to fix” and “build to succeed”, and shows why a structural problem should never be outsourced to an individual. It also looks at the two transitions happening at once, the founder’s and the CEO’s, and how to support the relationship between them through decision rights, rhythm, disagreement, feedback, support and evolution. Attendees leave with a clear view of the journey from diagnosis to independence, and a better question to ask: is this business genuinely ready for someone else to lead, and if not, what needs to change first?

